You see, I have thought that since Saige was about 2, that I would homeschool. I tried this past year to do pre-K at home with her. And it was a big. fat. fail. I liked the idea of us all being together as a family and wasn't ready to send her to school. But what I quickly learned was that I like to do whatever I want as a family. I like to keep my schedule. Grocery store, play dates, the zoo, the library, etc. And I know that is "all school." But when it came to sitting down and doing our letter of the week, well, I struggled. And on the days that we did do it, I didn't really enjoy it, although the girls wanted to do it all the time. I have absolutely no patience. I have absolutely no concept of what it means to teach a 3 and 4 year old. And I just kept telling myself that I will learn; that I needed to be more organized. That I will get better, and that I just need to be more disciplined and less selfish.
But what I have come to realize, by the grace of God, is that I have been holding onto this "other Cheryl." The one that has it all together. You know, the one that sews, crafts, bakes bread, cleans house, hosts parties, homeschools, and gets paid for it all. And while I ENJOY all of those things, I have realized that I am not doing the most important one well. Which is being a loving wife and mother. I am stressed and frazzled. And I like the idea of having more time with them at home. I like the idea that homeschool is more efficient. I like the idea that I would be the one teaching them everything. But I had to ask myself, at what cost will I hold onto my idealized world? At what cost, will I sacrifice my sanity and the sanity of those around me for my ideal, for my chimera? All the while, pushing back the giftings of the Lord that I aspire to do because I feel so stretched by the end of the day? Things like baking with my girls, painting with them, reading to them, and teaching them to run a home? I think since I know many women who are fully capable of doing those things AND homeschooling, I just assumed that, naturally, I could too. Hence my ideal had to become my reality.The Lord has shown me that I was holding onto "doing it all" because I didn't want to be perceived as the mom that "can't handle it." I didn't want people to think that I don't enjoy my children and that I want to ship them off as soon as they are able. I don't want people to perceive me as always wanting "me time." I wanted people to think that I can do it all. And secretly, I could do it better than them. Ugly, right? And when people would suggest I put them in school, it only made me dig my heels in deeper.
But through various friends, one husband and through His word, God has shown me that I need to let that "idealized Cheryl" go and be who He created me to be. The one that is forgetful, unorganized, creative, energetic and passionate. And that I can be more of those things when I am not spending my time trying to perfect the things that I am not good at. I am not saying that I shouldn't strive to be more organized. Because my mother can testify that having kids has forced me to be more structured and that I have gotten better at it over the years. But what I am saying is that I need to let go of the perfect version of that and just rest in doing my best.
"I have had more trouble with myself than with any other man I have ever met."
-Dwight Lyman Moody
I am seeing my heart idols, for what they are - sin. And at the women's retreat, I realized that one of those idols, is that I want just enough approval from everyone to be accepted in whatever circle I am in. But praise be to God, that His approval is all that matters. I need to stop striving and rest in His work and in His grace.
“As [the First] Commandment is the very first, highest and best, from which all the others proceed...so also its work, that is, faith or confidence in God’s favor at all times, is the very first, highest and best, from which all other [works] must proceed, exist, remain, be directed and measured.” - Martin LutherPatrick has been patient with me in this decision process. He has never wanted to come out and say, that we should put them in public school, because he wanted me to come to that conclusion on my own. I am thankful for his patience and long suffering. And I am super excited about the prospect of having a renewed sense of motherhood when Saige starts school. And although I am sure I will cry when I drop her off, like a real ugly cry, I know she will be just fine. God is sovereign. He cares and loves my children more than I do, and I am going to trust Him in that.
But I would love to hear your honest responses. So please leave me a comment.
~cheryl~

This is beautifully written. I have struggled with this myself as so many families at our church homeschool-except me, who chooses to teach women over homeschool her children. I figured that was what everyone thought, but I realized that the belief of "the real Godly woman homeschools" was coming from myself, not anyone else. The wonderful freeing realization for me is that each of my children is different as well as each year. So now, Shawn and I realize that we take it year by year, trusting that God will lead us individually with each child. For right now, that means public school. Next year? We'll worry about that as it comes closer. Anyways, it was a great post. Thanks for sharing.
ReplyDeleteI've been working through the same internal struggles!! Trying to figure out who I am and who I've been *trying* to be. I realized that a lot of what I did, I was obsessing about how it 'looked' or what people would think. Its a terrible way to live. God in His mercy is revealing all of this junk to me slowly so I can process it all. I hate to see who I really am, but its good to know I'm not alone. :) --Kathy
ReplyDeleteCheryl I am really loving your posts. I wish I would have read them when I was your age.(back when the cavemen were around). You are so wise and learning so much. God is teaching you things that most moms never learn. Good for you. You are a wonderful mother and whether you home school or send them to public schools you are still a wonderful mother. FYI - I cried when I took all three of mine to Kindergarten and COLLEGE. Yep, ask the kids. The boys hugged me and said "Mom, we will be home tomorrow". That wasn't the point!
ReplyDeleteWe have spent a lot of time talking about these issues and you know how I feel about homeschooling. But I hope you also know how I feel about you. You are one of my closest friends and I think you are a phenomenal mother. I do not doubt for a minute that your decision is intentional and well-thought out and I completely support you.
ReplyDeleteNow excuse me while I go shop for my denim jumper and Keds ;)
I think all moms travel the journey you described ... not necessarily the journey of school choice but the one of comparing ourselves with other moms, and comparing our children to other children. The journey is difficult, sometimes funny, often heart wrenching and enormously humbling.
ReplyDeleteOh, how we struggled with our schooling decision at the beginning, even though it was for different reasons, the struggle was daily. No matter our choice, we didn't really rest in that choice until we stopped looking around at others and questioning what we did based on what others were doing. And it is still hard, I still see other moms that have it so together and I just get so frustrated. Then I pop in another 'educational' dvd, grab my Sonic drink and rock my babies. What do you do? :o) Okay, maybe I don't always do that but it is what I should do!
The only wrong choice you can make is the one that isn't best for your family, your life, and the one that is not from Our Lord.
You are more organized then you probably think, you seem have it together but more importantly you children look content and loved! They will do great no matter what yall decide!
It's such a hard decision...I love that you care enough to really let Him speak to you and your husband.
ReplyDeleteWe're a "one year at a time" family...and I try to keep a "Lord willing" heart.
These are our list of questions that we work through each year for our 4.
God will give ya the wisdom He promises.
http://thechuppies.blogspot.com/2011/02/repost-because-its-getting-close-to.html
Matt Damon and his wife have four children. Alexia, Isabella, Gia, and Stella (STEEELLAAA). hahaha, I know, not the point.
ReplyDeleteI love you and I love this post and your honesty. And I hope you are able to rest a little better now that you've made a decision.
There are a lot of things I could say, but I will give you two (for now): 1) You are far more organized than you think. You make lists of things you want to do and, if you are honest with yourself, the lists are longer than the day. If you are able to love your family well and strike ONE thing off the list, you did well! I say this as I was finally shown that "the list" is more than I could accomplish in a week, let alone a day! 2) You made a wise decision, based on you and your family. Once Reed is a little older, you may change your mind and try it. I know people who have just home schooled "for a season" and had them in public school or private school for the rest of their education. Nothing saying you can't mix it up as time goes on! You need to give yourself more credit for your wisdom! This wasn't an impluse decision....
ReplyDeletePeanut,
ReplyDeleteMom and I think you are an awesome mom and are so much more spiritually mature at your age than we were.
I want to say THANK YOU for all your words of encouragement. I have been struggling with this decision for some time. It is nice to be reminded to take one year at a time and I am not deciding their entire future education in one year. I will keep you all updated on getting our baby girl registered, etc. Eek! I need to do that, huh?! ;)
ReplyDeleteI have had a little experience in homeschooling. I decided to teach Alex to read, and it was a blast, but all I could handle was about 30min-1hr per day. I had a really hard time getting the 2 year old sister to be quiet enough for him to concentrate. I have no idea how I could handle any more than what I did...and we also did not work on it every day, only when we felt like it. It took us 6 months to get through the book because little Teddy was born and we took 6 weeks off. So, he will be going off to school (private) 5 days a week next year and I will be crying right along with you. I still plan to teach him other things outside of school on my own, it has proven to be successful!
ReplyDeleteLoved reading this. We have always been able to "follow peace" as trite as that sounds where school has been concerned. I am encouraged also to see the areas where I am not accepting myself and should be.
ReplyDeleteOne idea that was very freeing to me in making this very important decision:
ReplyDeleteYou don't have to "start school" with Saige just because she is 5.
There are several books on delaying academics in lieu of some of the other things you mentioned (play, homemaking, serving..). I enjoyed Better Late Than Early by Raymond and Dorothy Moore.
The hard part is not letting yourself feel like a slacker because you are swimming against the majority of homeschoolers as well as friends whose kids are in public or private school. So the people pleaser in me winces every time I try to explain what we are doing (or, as the case may be, NOT doing).
Just know that at any point in this process, you can change your mind! You are earnestly seeking the Spirit. Be tender and willing and you will know what is right for your family.
Thank you SO much for this!!! You have no idea how much I needed to read this. I have one child in public school and one going in the fall, and struggle every day with whether I am making the right decision. I too feel like homeschooling sounds like such a great idea, but the reality of it, in my life, would leave me and my kids frazzled and frustrated. I pray all the time that God will give me wisdom, and that if at any time our school decision needs to change, that I will hear from Him loud and clear. It's nice to know there is someone else out there that feels the same way I do!!
ReplyDeleteHang in there, Cheryl. I too have been struggling with school issues too. Not with homeschooling, but whether to keep Emma at Montessori school for kindergarten (where she knows everyone, the teachers, etc and excels) or put her in public school where she will not know anyone or the methods of learning. In the end, we are doing public school. Remember, it's not a final decision. You can always change your mind later if it's not working. Saige will do great!! (Don't forget to look for kindergarten round up info. Ours starts next month.)
ReplyDeletethis is great stuff. educating our children has been one of the hardest decisions for us!! we take it one year at a time. so far we've been doing a university model school...my older boys go to school 2 days a week and i homeschool the other 3 days. so far it's been a good fit. but definitely not easy!!
ReplyDeleteThis is such a beautiful and amazing post. I found you through the Nester's incourage article, and I am grateful that I clicked my way to you. This is such a wonderful expression of something I have been dealing with before. I never considered the fact that my inability to enjoy or be more patient with teaching my children isn't something that God is trying to use to teach me to be MORE of those things. That rather, I should accept that I cannot be perfect and just enjoy myself and be myself and stop trying so hard to be something else.
ReplyDeleteThank you so much for your words.